November 19, 2026
This fall, two original houses came on the market in Upper Hermosa. They were built a year apart. The one at 5825 Folsom Drive dates to 1954. It has 1,409 square feet on about a quarter acre and horizon ocean views over the treetops. It sold for $2.45 million on September 30, 2026, after 34 days on the market, against a $2.5 million asking price. The one at 414 La Canada Street dates to 1953. It has 1,540 square feet on a 7,501-square-foot lot, and the listing records no view. It went pending at its $2.89 million asking price after 19 days and was still shown as pending in mid-November.
The smaller lot with no view was priced $440,000 above the larger lot with the ocean view. Our own Drew Nelson represented the seller on Folsom, so we watched that gap form from up close. It shows how this neighborhood prices its older houses. Buyers treat an original Upper Hermosa house as land and price the land by how much of it they can use. Add what it costs to build, and the total comes out close to what finished homes here have sold for. The original house doesn't save money. It buys control of the result.
Divide the Folsom sale by its living area and you get about $1,739 a square foot. In November 2025, a brand-new 8,516-square-foot home at 6260 Waverly Avenue sold for $15.5 million, which works out to about $1,820 a square foot. So a 1950s two-bedroom with one bath sold within about five percent of a 2025 coastal estate on that measure. Price per foot of house says almost nothing here, because nobody paid $2.45 million for 1,409 square feet of 1954 construction.
Lot area is the better measure, though it isn't the whole story either. The table covers the Upper Hermosa sales recorded between July 2025 and September 2026, plus the La Canada listing that is still pending. Dates are included because turnover is thin. The neighborhood recorded three closings in 2026 through mid-November.
| Address | Built | Lot (sq ft) | Home (sq ft) | List price | Sold price and date | Sold price per lot sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6260 Waverly Ave | 2025 | 31,798 | 8,516 | $16,750,000 | $15,500,000, Nov. 26, 2025 | about $487 |
| 6003 Waverly Ave | 1949 | 10,132 | 4,364 | $6,995,000 | $6,675,000, July 30, 2025 | about $659 |
| 5787 Bellevue Ave | 2007 | 16,200 | 4,191 | $4,625,000 | $3,985,000, Dec. 5, 2025 | about $246 |
| 778 La Canada St | 1990 | about 5,750 | 3,379 | $3,995,000 | $3,950,000, April 2026 | about $687 |
| 5825 Waverly Ave | 1970 | 8,200 | 2,252 | $3,995,000 | $3,767,000, Nov. 12, 2025 | about $459 |
| 5825 Folsom Dr | 1954 | about 10,450 | 1,409 | $2,500,000 | $2,450,000, Sept. 30, 2026 | about $234 |
| 414 La Canada St | 1953 | 7,501 | 1,540 | $2,890,000 | Pending at list, Nov. 2026 | about $385 at list |
The two highest prices per lot square foot went to homes a buyer could move into right away. At 778 La Canada, a 1990 house on about an eighth of an acre had ocean and canyon views and had been marketed as turn-key, with a newer roof, decks, siding and multi-zoned HVAC. It closed at $3.95 million after 28 days, about 1 percent below its asking price. At 6003 Waverly, the home was a 1949 historic Spanish residence with ocean views and modern updates. It went under contract in 14 days and closed at $6.675 million. Both of those houses are old. Age didn't push either one down to land value. The work a lot still needs did.
On paper, Folsom has what this part of La Jolla is known for. It has elevation, privacy, treetop vistas and horizon ocean views, and it is a few minutes from the shops and restaurants of Bird Rock. We were direct about the rest when we marketed it. The house sits above an oversized two-car garage, and the lot falls away behind it in a steep rear slope, which a buyer would have to plan around from the start. A buyer of that lot is paying for a view they will have to design, engineer and build their way into.
La Canada is a different kind of lot. The listing notes a generous 7,500-square-foot lot, a large garage, original condition and zoning described as RM-2-5. The structured listing field reads "R-2: Minor Multiple." The marketing pitched it to people planning to live there, to builders and to investors. By comparison, the listing for 778 La Canada, farther up the same street, shows R-1 single-family zoning. What any one parcel allows is a question for the City of San Diego and a buyer's own consultants. The pricing shows this much. A flatter lot that the listing describes as having more than one possible use, and that more than one kind of buyer might want, drew a pending contract at full price in under three weeks with no view at all.
Both sales point the same way. In Upper Hermosa, the view sets the ceiling on what a finished house can be worth, and how usable the lot is sets the price of the land underneath it. When the land needs heavy work before it can show off the view, the market takes that work off the price first.
A rough budget makes the comparison concrete. Ataman Studio, an architecture firm that works in La Jolla, publishes 2025–2026 planning ranges for custom homes in the area. It lists $700 to $1,000 or more per square foot on flat or gently sloped lots, $900 to $1,300 or more on hillside lots, and $1,300 to $2,000 or more for luxury or architecturally complex builds. These are planning numbers from one firm, not bids. The firm also notes that many La Jolla projects replace older houses on constrained sites.
Take Folsom at $2.45 million and assume a 3,500-square-foot home at the hillside range. Construction alone would come to roughly $3.15 million to $4.55 million, for an all-in total of about $5.6 million to $7 million. Now take La Canada at its $2.89 million asking price and assume a 3,500-square-foot home at the flat-lot range. Construction would come to roughly $2.45 million to $3.5 million, for a total of about $5.3 million to $6.4 million. The finished-home closings in the table fall right alongside those totals. 6003 Waverly brought $6.675 million for 4,364 square feet with ocean views, and buyers still had to wait out design and construction on the other path.
That is why we describe the original houses as land rather than as bargains. A buyer who starts at $2.45 million and builds ends up in about the same place as a buyer who pays for a finished home. Neither one gets a markdown. The first buyer gets to choose the floor plan, the finishes and how the house is set toward the view. A buyer who wants those choices badly enough to plan and carry a build is the one who belongs in this part of the market.
Look at the gap between list and sold price in the table and a pattern shows up. Homes priced for what they already were, at either end of the age range, sold close to their asking prices. Folsom closed at 98 percent of its asking price, 778 La Canada at about 99 percent and 6003 Waverly at about 95 percent. The deeper reductions came in the middle and at the very top. 5787 Bellevue, a 2007 contemporary on 16,200 square feet with ocean views, came down from $4.625 million and closed at $3.985 million, about 86 percent of its original asking price, after 75 days. The new 6260 Waverly took 113 days and closed about 7.5 percent below its $16.75 million asking price.
Bellevue's listing mentioned renovated baths, new paint and a newer bonus room. That puts it between the two types of home buyers paid near-full price for. It was updated but not new, and it sat on a large lot that a rebuild buyer could have priced as land. A home in that position has to win over the turnkey buyer and the builder at once. In this set of sales, that took time and a lower number. Buyers paid near-full price for houses that were clearly one thing or the other.
For a buyer comparing Upper Hermosa with other parts of La Jolla, this sets the plan. If you want an original house, look first at how much of the lot you can build on and at how it is described for zoning, then at the view. If you want a finished home, the fastest sales in this set went to houses the market could judge at a glance, whether that meant a well-kept 1949 Spanish or a turn-key 1990 house. Our Upper Hermosa neighborhood page covers the streets and architecture. Our earlier piece on upsizing to Upper Hermosa covers the move-up decision.
Is a $2.5 million original house in Upper Hermosa a way into the neighborhood at a discount? Only if you plan to live in the house largely as it is. Priced as a home to rebuild, it is the land component of a finished house, and the build costs above bring the total in line with recent finished-home sales.
Do ocean views always raise the price of an original house? In this set of sales, a view lot with a steep rear slope sold for less than a smaller lot with no view and a broader range of possible uses. The view adds the most value once a house is built to take advantage of it.
How often do these houses come up? Rarely. The neighborhood recorded three closed sales in 2026 through mid-November. One of those was an original house, and a second original house was pending.
Two original houses in one season is unusual for Upper Hermosa. The Nelson Brothers Team handled the Folsom sale and can show you how a lot like it compares with a finished home on your short list, with the lot math worked through before you write an offer. If you own an original Hermosa house and want to know whether buyers would price it as a home or as land, our La Jolla home valuation is a good place to start. Let's connect.
We are Drew and Tim Nelson of the Nelson Brothers Team at Willis Allen Real Estate. Having closed on over $1B+ of sales volume, and over $114M in 2022, we are one of the top producing teams specializing in coastal luxury real estate and investment
property in La Jolla - where we were born, raised and currently reside with our families. We both went to the University of Southern California, where Drew earned a BA in Finance and Business Economics with a concentration in Real Estate, and Tim
completed the Marshall School of Business Entrepreneurship Program. The combination of our collective experience, knowledge, and resources allows us to offer our clients more. More expertise. More responsiveness. More ideas. More solutions.
More success. More of what you deserve from your real estate agent!
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
November 19, 2026
November 12, 2026
November 5, 2026
October 29, 2026
October 27, 2026
The Best Homes in La Jolla Feature Lavish Outdoor Living.
October 27, 2026
Delving Into the Factors that Determine ROI in La Jolla.
October 27, 2026
Find Your New Favorite Spa Upon Moving to La Jolla.
October 27, 2026
From Finding Neighborhood Fit to Securing Local Guidance.
October 22, 2026
The combination of our collective experience, knowledge, and resources allows us to offer our clients more. More expertise. More responsiveness. More options. More ideas. More solutions. More success. More of what you deserve from your real estate agent!